Gravitational Forces
Economic production (in money terms) per hour worked. Pink is the property sector; then financial services, utilities, manufacturing, health and education, agriculture and hospitality.
Share this image
The greatest “productivity” in money terms occurs in areas of the economy that do not produce anything new at all.
Adam Smith’s discussion of free market economics famously involved the manufacture of steel pins. The production consisted of pins, and the number of pins produced per period of work was the measure of productivity. More pins produced by fewer people or in less time should mean more income for pin makers and cheaper pins for consumers, so winners all round.
What works for pins, however, does not work in the case of service activities. In these, the quantity of what is produced – in effect, the total amount of the usefulness of the activity – is less easily counted. So instead of counting actual production, statisticians assume that the amount of money the activity is able to retain for itself, in wages and profits, is an accurate measure of its output.. The more money retained per hour worked, the more productive the activity is said to be.
This image shows production value per hour for various activities, each shown as a circle, sized according to its value. The big pink circle is property and rent, where productivity is calculated at £289 per hour worked. This figure includes “imputed rent” – the rent that home owners would pay if they didn’t own their home, in effect a rent that they are paying to themselves.
Imputed rent is included here because it is also included in the calculation of GDP. When rents and house prices go up, so does GDP, even though nothing new is created. (When the rent on a house increases, it is still the same house.) Productivity is high in money terms because people don’t have to work many hours to receive rent on their property.
The red circle is financial services, at £101 per hour. This is another area that extracts and redistributes money – usually upwards to the already-rich – rather than producing anything new of value.
After that, in the teal circle, comes energy and water, at £91 per hour. That high number suggests that supplying clean water, well-treated sewage and affordable oil, gas and electricity is not the primary business motivation of these companies. Natural monopolies, huge subsidies and lax regulation allow them to extract high profits, even while employing relatively few people.
The remaining circles are manufacturing, with production valued at £45 per hour; healthcare and education, at £30 per hour on average; agriculture, at £27 per hour and the hospitality industry – hotels and restaurants, where pay is generally low, at £21 per hour. These are all genuinely productive activities, but the value of their production is considered to be far lower than that of property and finance.
For proponents of free market dogma, these money amounts are all they need or know. If money is, by definition, always allocated in the most useful way, then the more money that is retained or accumulated by an activity, the more worthwhile that activity must be.
But if free market dogma is going to cure the UK’s economic malaise, it would have done so by now. Its basic mistake is to think of money as an output of work. Although we talk colloquially of paid work as “making money” (turning work into money), that’s not what is happening. Paid work may accumulate money as it flows through the system, but the money is already there, making work possible by paying for materials and resources. So money is an input to work, not an output – the rain on the garden or the oil in the engine, so to speak.
Looked at like this, the true measure of productivity should not be how much money can be accumulated in an hour’s work, but how much real wealth can be produced for the input of as little money as possible. That way, money can be spread as widely as possible, allowing many more people to create the real wealth that will improve the quality of their lives.
Data sources: ONS productivity statistics, 2022


