Tax for Rich People
UK government borrowing, by type of lender: UK pension and insurance funds (yellow); UK banks (green); UK investors (blue); foreign (red) and the Bank of England (clear).
Share this image
If the government can create as much money as it wants, why does it borrow? This image addresses that question by looking at who the government is borrowing from.
On the left we have, in yellow, UK pension and insurance funds. Here the government is taking people’s long-term savings and using them to support its spending. By paying interest on its borrowing, it contributes to the growth of those savings. The money stays in the UK economy and so it is a win-win all round.
Next, in green are the UK banks. Owning gilts (UK government debt) helps to keep their balance sheets in good shape. In blue we’ve got UK private investors, hedge funds, that sort of thing. This is where the image gets its title “Tax for Rich People”, because government borrowing, like tax, is a method of taking money out of the economy so that government spending can put it back. If the government just created new money to spend, without taking any out, there would be too much sloshing around and we would get rampant inflation. Tax and borrowing are the two chief methods of taking money out. The difference is that borrowing gets paid back with interest, whereas tax does not.
So that’s all borrowing from the UK, and in red on the right we have borrowing from abroad. This is the biggest single source of UK government borrowing, and it doesn’t help the UK economy in the long term because the interest paid ends up in the hands of foreign investors. Why is so much UK government debt foreign-owned? The answer lies in the difference between the UK’s imports and exports, including its investment income. The UK imports far more than it exports, and it pays out in dividends and other investment returns much more than it receives. So a lot of the UK’s money ends up in foreign hands. And the government has to find ways to get it back to balance the books.
One way to get it back is to sell things, like property, businesses and national assets like water and energy companies. Another way is to borrow it, which the government does in large quantities. The big problem with this is the interest payments. These add to the outflow of UK money, so more asset sales to foreigners, or more borrowing, is needed.
The final part of the image is the one that is missing. The square outline with nothing in it is the money that currently the government is borrowing from the Bank of England. And the reason why it’s empty is that it’s not actual borrowing at all. The government owns the Bank of England so it doesn’t have to pay it back. It doesn’t have to pay interest on it. It’s just borrowing the money from itself by creating new money when it needs it.
Every debt is an asset. I owe you money and pay you interest. You have an asset (my debt to you) which is paying you an income. So government borrowing is also creating assets for others, which is fine if those assets are in the UK, but less so if they are going abroad. Ultimately the problem for the UK economy is not government debt, since the government can create the money that it needs. The problem is that the UK does not produce enough to meet its needs. So it has to import the difference from abroad, and it can only afford to pay for it by borrowing from foreigners or selling them its assets.


