Missing the Point
Cabinet Ministers, 1922 to 2021. The pink box shows the total number, the green box shows those who went to university and the blue box shows those who went to Oxford or Cambridge.
Share this image
Policy-makers are generally “on the way up”, and they tend to think that everybody else is, too.
The image shows the education of the 479 cabinet ministers who served between 1922 and 2021. That total is represented by the pink box, if you think of it as solid. Within that box, in green, are the 413 who went to university, and within the green box, in blue, are the 243 who went to Oxford or Cambridge Universities. That’s just over half.
It may be no surprise that almost all cabinet ministers over the last 100 years have been to university, but until very recently that would make them hugely unrepresentative of the experience of the population at large. The fact that over half went to one of the two most prestigious universities may be more surprising, but it speaks to the levels of aspiration or privilege that is associated with achieving cabinet rank.
The problem, however, is not that successful politicians are either privileged or high achievers. The problem is the group-think that can occur when everybody involved in policy-making is cast from that mould. In a modern state like the UK, pretty much everybody involved in policy-making or decision-making in government is aspirational, or “on the way up”. They are well educated, sufficiently wealthy and in well-paid jobs, and they’re broadly surrounded by people in similar circumstances. So that’s normal for them, and achievable; it’s the level at which they imagine the society should operate because that’s what they see all around them.
What this means is that people who are nowhere near that level, people right at the margins, people who are most deprived, become invisible. From a policy point of view they feel like an aberration in the system. Policy-makers tend to look at average outcomes, and often “average” and “normal” can seem like the same thing. If a government can achieve a good outcome on average, then it may think it’s doing pretty well regardless of what’s happening below that level or at the very bottom.
If what’s happening at the bottom of the social and economic scale can be treated as an aberration, it can be easy to ignore. And this is reinforced by an aspirational tendency to look up rather than down, to aspire to what other people have who are doing better, rather than to see how much better off we are than the people below us.
So this is not really an image of university attendance. It’s an image of shared experience and the dangers of generalising based on a perceived “normal”. Because that leaves no room for individual experience, and individual experience is how people live their lives. To summarise: economic growth is all very well, but it’s only really worth having if it improves the lot of ordinary people, which often it does not.


